The reviews reflect a mixed experience with the cottage show, particularly highlighting the contrast between the well-received spring show and the disappointing fall show. Many attendees appreciated the location and management of the event, noting the well-organized setup and friendly vendors. However, several reviewers expressed dissatisfaction with the fall show's focus on crafts and non-cottage related items, feeling that it did not deliver value for the cost. Overall, while the spring show garnered high praise, the fall show received significant criticism, suggesting a need for improvement in content relevance.