Camp Mather receives a mixed response from visitors, highlighted by overwhelmingly positive experiences centered around its enchanting atmosphere, diverse activities, and family-friendly environment. Many families cherish the variety of engaging outdoor activities available, exceptional meals, and the comforting accommodations. However, one review pointed out a distressing incident at the pool involving aggressive behavior from a staff member, which significantly marred the experience for a visitor with young children. Overall, while the campsite excels in creating lasting memories for many, attention to staff conduct is essential for ensuring a consistently enjoyable experience.